Plumpton Notes: Part 4
Index 13. Canopy Management 14. Sustainable Viticulture
13. Canopy Management
13.1 Introduction
Canopy management is the organisation of the grapevine plant's shoots, leaves and fruit to maximise the quality of the microclimate surrounding them, thus improving quality and yield.
It is particularly important in cool-climate areas.
Since the Second World War, technological advances (particularly in vine nutrition and pest control) and the planting of vines on fertile soils have increased problems of vine vigour leading to poor canopy management.
Canopy management in viticulture was first developed in grapevines by Nelson Shaulis (Cornell University), and further extended by Alain Carbonneau of the University of Montpellier and Richard Smart, formerly of the Ruakura Agricultural Centre in New Zealand.
See: Smart R & Robinson M Sunlight into wine. Winetitles
13.2 The Main Aims of Canopy Management
To maximise the effectiveness of light interception by vine canopies:
- Present a large canopy surface to the sun
- Encourage early development of that canopy in the spring
- Avoid inter-row shading by having a maximum ratio of canopy height to alley width of 1:1
To reduce canopy shading, particularly in the cluster/renewal zone:
- In highly shaded leaves, the rate of respiration outstrips that of photosynthesis, so the leaf consumes rather than produces energy
- Shade reduces the viability and success of floral initiation in dormant buds, thus causing an imbalance between leaf area and fruit weight leading to Smart’s vegetative cycle.
- Shaded flowers have lower rates of successful fertilisation and fruit set
- Shaded berries keep cooler and so do not ripen as well in cool climates
- Shaded fruit have lower-quality flavours and colours, as some of the
biochemical reactions that produce these are stimulated by sunlight - Shaded fruit and leaves have far greater risks of contracting fungal diseases, especially powdery mildew and grey rot
To produce a uniform microclimate for fruit:
- A uniform microclimate leads to more synchronised ripening, which leads to a greater chance of picking at the optimum period.
To achieve an appropriate distribution of the products of photosynthesis:
- Too much fruit and not enough leaves (over-cropping) will generate poor-quality fruit and reduce vine vigour
- Too many leaves and not enough fruit will cause over-vigorous growth, which will also produce poor-quality fruit.
To arrange the locations of individual organs in restricted zones in space:
- This facilitates mechanisation, particularly in pruning, pesticide application and harvesting
The first step in canopy management is diagnosis.
13.3 Assessing Canopy Quality
The Richard Smart Vineyard Scorecard (on the next page) can be used from veraison to harvest to assess the quality of canopies.
In order to obtain data for this scorecard, a point quadrat technique can be used:
- A sharpened metal rod is stabbed 50 times into the canopy at right angles in the fruit zone in random areas.
- Contacts with leaves (L), clusters © and canopy gaps (G) are noted.
% Canopy Gaps = (Number of Gs / 50) x 100
Optimum 40 % Canopy Gaps Mean leaf layer number = (Total number of Ls/ 50)
Optimum 1 – 1.5 leaves Fruit exposure = (Number of external Cs/ Total number of Cs ) x 100
Optimum 60% fruit exposure
13.4 Canopy Management Techniques
13.4.1 Site Assessment
This is done by:
- digging a soil profile
- assessing the water supply
- soil fertility tests
- Observing the performance of plants on a similar soil
Smart classes sites into three categories:
- High potential sites: Deep (> 1 m), fertile soils, good water supply, high nutrient levels.
- These require low-density planting (< 3000 plants/ha) and complex trellis systems, such as RT2T & GDC
- Medium potential sites: Soils 0.5 – 1m deep, adequate water supply and average fertility
- These require average plant densities (3000 – 5000 plants/ha) and systems such as Lyre, Scott-Henry and large VSP
- Low potential sites: soils less than 0.5 m deep, poor water availability during the growing season and low fertility.
- High-density (> 5000 plants/ha) VSP systems can be used on these sites.
13.4.2 Trellis selection
Criteria for assessing trellis systems:
- Legislation
- Plant density, alley width and trunk length requirements
- Features of site, e.g. frost susceptibility, wind exposure.
- Effectiveness of light interception (total exposed canopy surface/ha)
- Quality of canopy microclimate
- Cost & time of establishment (posts, wire, plants)
- Cost and time of maintenance (pruning, shoot positioning)
- Mechanisability (harvest, pruning etc...)
- Popularity and attractiveness
13.4.3 Winter Pruning
Reasons for pruning vines:
- To organise the plant on the trellis
- To allow for the passage of machinery and manpower
- To produce a balance between the crop and leaf area
13.4.4 Vigour Control
Excessively low vigour is generally due to:
- Drought stress —> Irrigation
- Low soil fertility —> Increase fertilisation, drainage, soil organic matter, etc.
- Disease —> Diagnose & treat
Excessively high vigour can be more difficult to control.
Possible strategies include:
- Selection of low vigour rootstocks
- Water stress in irrigated vineyards
- Cover cropping in alleys
- High-density planting: this only works in low-potential sites
- Removing alternate vines along the row: this allows vines to spread along a greater length of trellis, thus reducing shoot vigour and canopy density
- Root pruning: a subsoiling tine is passed through the vineyard at 30 – 50 cm from the vine row after harvest or pre-budburst. Difficult to predict response as pruning will stimulate root growth.
- Retro-fitting a more complex trellis system: e.g., going from VSP to Scott Henryby increasing post length
13.4.5 Shoot Positioning
Shoot removal or bud-rubbing Vine shoots are removed if they are:
- Badly positioned and so will have to be removed at winter pruning anyway
- In contact or too close to the ground (Peronospora)
- Infertile (low-yielding plants)
- Rootstock shoots
- Causing too much canopy shade, particularly if growing in the centre of the plant, thus causing shade in the renewal zone for cane-pruned systems. Aim for 15 shoots/metre of trellis
- Supplementary to those left during winter pruning, the fruit/leaf surface ratio is affected.
- Laterals
This operation should be carried out after the risk of spring frosts but before flowering. It should not be done too severely on young plants.
Often done by hand (17 ~ 50 hours/ha), but shoots can be removed from the trunks by machines or herbicides (half-dose Paraquat)
Tucking in
- The aim is to organise the canopy and facilitate mechanisation.
- Important that upright canopies or shoots will bunch together and flop onto the ground, preventing the passage of machinery.
- Can be done by hand, using moveable wires, or with machines.
- Also important in downward-growing canopies, as shoots will resist growing downwards and form irregular canopies.
13.4.6 Summer Pruning
This is the least effective method of canopy management.
Pinching
- The selective removal of shoot tips around flowering. Usually done manually.
- The aims are to regularise shoot growth and improve the berry set.
- In vigorous vines, this leads to an increase in the development of lateral shoots, so these have to be removed.
Trimming The cutting off of shoot extremities, either by hand or by machine.
Objectives:
- Control excessive shoot growth to facilitate the passage of manpower and machinery and reduce inter-row shading and wind damage
- Reduce canopy thickness to improve the microclimate and increase spray penetration
- Encourage the onset of maturity by discouraging shoot growth, which stimulates berry development
- To look good
Trimming normally starts in July after the last tucking-in. It should not be done too early or too severely.
Leaf stripping Removing leaves around the fruit zone, usually between veraison & berry ripening. Usually done by hand, but can be done by machine.
Objectives:
- Improve canopy microclimate, thus improving fruit quality
- Improve fruit health
- Improve spray penetration
- Increases speed of manual harvesting
Aim for 60% bunch exposure, but it should not be too severe in one pass. It can take up to 70 hours/ha!
For northern hemisphere vineyards:
- In N —> S rows, start on the Eastern side and only do the Western side in cool climates
- In E —> W rows, start on the Northern side and only do the Southern in cool climates
Crop thinning or green harvesting The removal of flowers or berries to regulate the crop.
Essential in very young vines to help them get established.
The aim is to:
- Control leaf area: fruit ratio so as to get optimum ripeness
- Conform with legal control on yields
Usually, the bunches on laterals and those nearest the shoot tips are removed.
If done too early (pre-veraison), vines will react by increasing the rate of berry cell division, thus increasing berry size.
It will be less effective if done post-veraison, as sugars will already have moved into the berries. So best done around veraison.
Usually done by hand: a very laborious task that will take around 50 hours/ha.
It can be done by a chemical spray (Ethrel C), but not recommended, as the results are unpredictable.
13.5 Conclusions
Canopy management theory has influenced New World viticulture considerably, particularly in areas of high vine vigour. Many varied training systems have been developed and are used commercially.
14. Sustainable Viticulture
14.1 Organic Viticulture
14.1.1 Principles
Aims:
- To coexist with, rather than dominate natural systems:
- Enhancement of biological cycles
- Maintenance of ecological diversity within and around cropped land by managing habitats such as banks, hedges, ponds, etc.
- To sustain or build soil fertility (“feed the soil, not the plant”)
- Use of crop rotations
- Rational use of manure and vegetable wastes
- Use of appropriate cultivation techniques
- To minimise damage to the environment
- In particular, avoid mineral salt fertilisers and agrochemical pesticides
- To minimise the use of non-renewable resources
Regulation:
- Guidelines are laid down by IFOAM (the International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements)
- Enshrined in EU regulation 2092/91 (July 22 1991)
- Regulations enforced by the UK Register of Organic Food Standards, a division of Food from Britain. This body receives notifications from operators, inspects Organic growers, and approves and supervises private inspection bodies (Approved Sector Bodies)
- The Soil Association is an Approved Sector Body (one of 5 in the UK), but the only one to approve vineyards. Founded in 1946 to research and promote Organic practices and guardian of the Soil Association symbol. Registration is currently about £300 plus an annual fee of 0.25% of sales (minimum £300, maximum £5000)
14.1.2 Production Standards
Record keepin Must keep physical and financial records of:
- Brought-in materials (e.g. fertilisers and sprays)
- Brought-in plants (noting things such as source, status and any treatments during propagation)
- Field cropping histories
- Details of manure, fertiliser and spray applications
Conversion from conventional production systems
- A 3-year plan designed to result in a viable and sustainable system operating to full organic standards must be drawn up by the grower.
- This must include a soil fertility-building stage with details of crop rotation, manure management and appropriate cultivations.
- Conversion must take place on a farm or part of a farm that is large enough to be viable and free from pollution from spray drift, traffic and factories
- Prohibited inputs may not be used at any stage during the conversion.
- This conversion plan must be submitted to a Certification Committee appointed by the Approved Sector Body, which reviews and monitors it at least once a year.
- In-conversion produce may be sold using the wording “Soil Association approved Organic conversion” or “IOFGA approved organic conversion.”
Soil Management Developing and protecting optimum soil structure and fertility is the main goal of Organic soil management.
Optimum soil structure is described as: “a water-stable, organically enriched, granular structure where all the water reserves within aggregates can be fully exploited by root hairs and the space between aggregates will be large enough to allow rapid drainage to admit air and to facilitate the deep penetration of roots” (Elm Farm Research Centre; The Soil 1984).
In order to attain this, the following recommendations are made:
- Regular input of organic residues
- The encouragement of a high level of activity in soil organisms, particularly micro-organisms
- A protective covering of vegetation, if applicable, and in particular, the use of green manure
- Appropriate cultivations, well timed, which achieve a deep loosening of the soil but avoid damage to the existing structure.
Crop rotations These are recommended to:
- Aid the maintenance of soil fertility, in particular, soil organic matter levels and soil structure
- Provide adequate nutrients and reduce nutrient losses
- Minimise weed, pest and disease problems
Manure management In Organic systems, there must be maximum recycling and minimum losses of materials.
All brought-in or conventionally produced manures must be approved by the Certification Committee and must be composted before use.
Compost heaps should be covered up and maintained for at least three months. High temperatures (optimum 60°C) are recommended to destroy weed seeds, pathogens, chemical residues and antibiotics.
Brought-in manures from un-organic farms are ‘restricted’ (permission from the Certification Committee must be sought), and manures from ethically unacceptable livestock systems are prohibited.
The maximum levels of heavy metals in manures and soils are controlled.
Care must be taken to avoid contamination of waterways or underground water in manure storage, handling or spreading.
Supplementary nutrients Mineral fertilisers should be regarded as a supplement to, and not a replacement for, nutrient recycling within the farm.
Only fertilisers that release nutrients through an intermediate process, such as weathering or the activity of soil organisms, are allowed, but ‘restricted’ use of highly soluble nutrients is allowed to treat severe mineral deficiencies.
Weed control The objective is to suppress rather than eliminate weed populations by:
- Crop rotation
- Manure management
- Fertilisation
- Utilisation of green manures
The short-term use of plastic mulching is permitted, but all synthetic herbicides are prohibited.
Pest control Emphasis is on prevention rather than cure.
Key control methods:
- Good husbandry or hygiene
- Balanced supply of plant nutrients
- Use of resistant varieties
- Creation of an ecosystem that encourages predators (e.g. use of hedgerows, plant breaks, companion planting)
The routine use of Bordeaux mixture and sulphur is restricted, but all other pesticides approved on vines are prohibited. ‘Pesticides’ based on plant extracts (e.g. horsetail, onion, garlic, tansy, wormwood, stinging nettle, rhubarb, regania, neem, quassia, pyrethrum, rotenone) are permitted.
Conservation Prohibited practices include:
- Drainage of wetlands
- Hedge trimming between the end of March & beginning of September
13.1.3 Conclusions
Still a very small part of the English Wine sector, but rapidly expanding in countries such as Italy (30,000 ha), Germany & France.
14.2. Biodynamic Viticulture
14.2.1 Introduction
Derived from the work of Rudolph Steiner (1861 – 1925), an Austrian social philosopher, founder of ‘anthroposophy’ and a Theosophist in later life.
Ms Maria Thun and her team in Germany & Holland developed a Biodynamic farming method. This method is not prescriptive but is, above all, a base for individual work inciting each person to develop personal relationships with his environment.
In 1998, there were 15,000 hectares of Biodynamic vines in France 200 hectares in the USA.
The approach is highly spiritual and rather intangible, but some of the basic principles include:
- A holistic (almost anthropomorphic) approach to the planet Earth
- Earth having a ‘cosmic’ relationship with the other planets in the Universe
- The plant is sensitive to these ‘life forces’, and so its cultivation must consider cosmic aspects. Different arrangements of the sun, moon, and planets will favour different parts of the plant, such as the roots, leaves, flowers or fruit.
- Cultural methods and products are employed that aim to channel cosmic forces in the plant and soil, making them vibrate in harmony with the universe
14.2.2 Biodynamic Practices
As Earth and the plants are sensitive to ‘cosmic’ forces, interventions must be governed by the positions of the planets (particularly the sun and the moon) in the zodiac.
For example:
- Root and fruit days are best for planting
- Fruit days are best for cultivating and any treatment that aims to produce quality fruit
Three preparations (or ‘medicines’ are used), which must be ‘dynamised’ by putting the product in water and mixing in a special way for a precise period of time:
1. Dung compost or Maria Thun (502 – 506)
- Made up mainly of cow dung, silica, limestone and various plant-based preparations (such as chamomile, nettle, oak-bark and dandelion)
- For soil applications: supports and reinforces the decomposition of organic matter
2. Horn dung (500)
- Made of dung placed in a cow’s horn that is buried over winter, where it fills up with vitalising energy.
- It activates the elements of the soil towards the plant, thus stimulating root development. This enables better absorption of nutrients and enhances drought resistance.
3. Horn silica (501)
- Made of finely ground silica placed in a cow’s horn and buried during the summer, where it becomes energised by the sun’s forces.
- It treats the atmosphere to allow light forces to reach the plant and helps assimilation by the leaves of micronutrients found in the atmosphere in homoeopathic quantities.
Biodynamic growers also use compost and manure for plant nutrition.
The aim is to produce plants with ‘harmony’ that defend themselves rather than attract pests.
However, growers are still permitted to use Bordeaux mixture (3 kg/ha) and sulphur (7 kg/ha), but are encouraged to use natural herb concoctions.
Dynamised ashes of target pests (e.g. insects or rabbits) sprayed onto the foliage are also used to control pests.
14.2.3 Conclusions
Some growers come to Biodynamics through the philosophy, but most begin by applying the practices.
Growers claim to have healthy vineyards, improved wines, improved health, and the ‘honour of participating in the regeneration of our planet’.
However, they have increased monitoring of the vineyard and are constrained by the Seedling Calendar, which over-rides public holidays, etc.
14.3 Integrated Viticulture
Developed by the International Organisation for Biological Control (IOBC) over 40 years. Has it roots in IPM.
Now firmly established in Switzerland (7000 hectares) and Southern Germany.
Definition: Integrated Production is a system that produces high-quality food and other products by using natural resources and regulating mechanisms to replace polluting inputs and to secure sustainable farming.
14.3.1 Aims
A holistic approach whose main aims are:
- Better management of resources
- Viewing the entire farm as the basic unit
- Balanced nutrient cycles
- Preservation and improvement of soil fertility
- Environmental protection
- The central role of agro-ecosystems
- Maintenance of a diversified environment
- Improved crop quality
- Economics
14.3.2 Guidelines
Guidelines for Integrated Production of Grapes (IOBC 1999):
- To promote viticulture that respects the environment, is economically viable, and sustains the multiple functions of agriculture, namely its social, cultural and recreational aspects
- To secure sustainable production of healthy grapes of high quality and with a minimum occurrence of pesticide residues
- To protect the farmers’ health while handling agro-chemicals
- To promote and maintain a high biological diversity in the ecosystem of the vineyard and in surrounding areas
- To give priority to the use of natural regulating systems
- To preserve and promote long-term soil fertility
- To minimise the pollution of water, soil and air
14.3.3 Recommended Practices
Practices that are promoted to meet these principles are:
- Reduction in chemical inputs, particularly broad-spectrum pesticides in order to protect and enhance natural regulating mechanisms
- The establishment of a permanent or temporary green cover in regions with precipitation above 700 mm/year, thus increasing the biodiversity and ecological stability of the system and encouraging insect predators and parasitoids and controlling pests. This also controls the nitrogen cycle, reduces erosion, improves soil structure and reduces nutrient loss
- The proper management of that cover (alternate mowing) to allow a constant supply of flowering plants
- The mowing of the cover crop to synchronize the nitrogen availability in the soil with the nitrogen demand of the grapevine
- For new vineyards, the selection and harmonisation of new sites, rootstocks, cultivars and planting systems to produce regular yields of quality grapes with minimum use of agro-chemicals and environmentally hazardous practices
- The training and pruning of grapevines to achieve a balance between growth and regular yields and to allow good penetration of light and sprays
- The proper ventilation of the grape zone in humid areas
- The conservation of soil quality and life by recycling nutrients and restricting the quantities of fertiliser used
- The avoidance of groundwater pollution with fertilisers, especially nitrates
- Irrigation only applied according to need, on close monitoring of soil water content
- Priority on plant protection given to indirect preventative measures (such as the use of resistant cultivars, appropriate training systems, and avoidance of excess nitrogen), followed by direct control measures, if necessary based on economic thresholds, risk assessment and forecasting services
- At least two key natural pest parasitoids or predators must be identified or introduced, then protected and augmented.
- Populations of pests and diseases must be regularly monitored and recorded using scientifically established assessment methods appropriate to the region.
- Any treatments must be based on scientifically established threshold levels and scientific forecasts of pest risk.
14.3.4 Implementation
To gain endorsement by the IOBC, viticulturists form IP-organisations that submit statutes, guidelines and protocols. These can vary regionally.
For certification, the grower submits complete records on fertilisers, pesticides and cultural practices and is subject to unannounced inspection at least once a year.
The performance of the grape growers is evaluated annually using a point system or Bonus-Malus system:
- No points are given to traditional practices that do not make use of ‘softer’ alternatives
- Bonus points are given to practices that are in line with IP guidelines
- Any practice that violates IP objectives is given a Malus point and causes the disqualification of the respective farmer as an IP grower.
Certain levels of Bonus points, say 50%, are required for a grower to be approved in a regional IP association, e.g. VINATURA in Switzerland.